四大顶流AI绘图模型真实评测 - Midjourney、Adobe、SD、DALLE

昨天，Adobe正式发布了他们新一代的AI绘图大模型：Adobe Firefly 3.

细节更强、语义理解更强、控制性更强等等。

还发了新一版本的PS AI。

不过这些不是重点。

AdobeFirefly 3的发布，结合前段时间发布的SD3.让我有了再一次搞一个AI绘图大模型竞技场，评测一下的想法。

上一次做AI绘图的综合评测还在去年12月1号：

四大巨头的AI绘图模型综合评测 - 写在Meta Imagine上线后

那时候Midjourney还没发V6.stability也没发SD3.

在现在这个节点，过了近半年的时候，来再看一下现在进化过的巨头们，已经达到了什么样的水平。

四家分别为：

Midjourney V6、AdobeFirefly 3、Stable Diffusion 3、Dalle 3.

至于评测方式，我依然会从细节质量、审美（构图色彩等）、语义理解这三个维度来评测，剔除掉了风格多样化这个指标(没法测)。

细节质量、审美、语义理解每个类别14个case，总和42个Case(42这个数字的代表意义懂的都懂哈哈哈哈)

同时每个Prompt我会在AI绘图模型中roll3次出12张图，取效果最具有代表性的那个图，尽量减少偏见。同时为了保证公平，基本不会搞特别复杂的prompt。

同时，为了有最后整体可视化的评分让大家看着更直观，所以我会进行打分。在每个案例中，第一名为4分，第二为3分，第三为2分，最后一名为1分，最后计算平均分。

虽然每个case数量都不是很多，但是这也差不多了，而且是我个人的极限了。为了避免文章太长阅读体验极差，我就每个类别只放8个Case来做展示。

OK，让我们开始吧。

一. 细节质量

主要测试AI绘图对于细节的表现能力，比如人物面部皮肤的质感、比如织物纹理的细节、场景细微元素的细节等等，这个是对模型精度和输出质量一个非常重要的考量。

1.Prompt：

Selfie of charming kpop girl, outdoors, evening time, brunette, casual giggle, 2 bun tied hairstyle

Midjourney > SD3>Adobe >Dalle

-

2.Prompt：

Portrait of a 2000s blonde woman posing on a sports car, white wired headphones, expressionless, 2000s hairstyle, 2000s fashion, sun rays, light teal and amber,Cinestill 50D

Midjourney > SD3>Adobe>Dalle

-

3.Prompt：

Photo of smiling Labrador wearing sunglasses and straw hat sitting on the beach bench with glass of cocktail, beach scene, realistic

Midjourney > SD3>Adobe>Dalle

-

4.Prompt：

a sports car drifting in a middle of partitions in a festival of vape and there is people around the car vaping, cinematic mood

SD3>Adobe>Midjourney >Dalle

-

5.Prompt：

Realistic illustrations,The drumstick hits the frame and the drum bounces up water droplets

Midjourney >Adobe >Dalle>SD3

-

6.Prompt：

a house design inside of the perfect beach house, rustic malibu in style, the beach and surf included in the photos, Photography

Midjourney >Adobe>SD3>Dalle

-

7.Prompt：

beautiful blonde model made out of porcelain, long hair, wearing sci-fi light mecha armor, in the style of balanced symmetry, white and blue LED lights on armor

Midjourney > SD3 > Adobe > Dalle

-

8.Prompt：

Delicious hamburger, floating in the air, food professional photography, studio lighting, studio background

Midjourney > Adobe> SD3> Dalle

-

剩下case略。

在细节质量部分，Midjourney基本以绝对的优势压倒性胜利。

二. 审美

主要测试AI绘图的审美能力，一张图好不好看，是美是丑，除了细节之外，更多的还需要看模型的审美能力，比如构图、色彩、光影等等，审美强，出的图才好看。

1.Prompt：

Creatures from the Book of Mountains and Seas of China, a golden alien tiger with a resting bird on its back, attack posture, with light and golden particles emitting in the air

Midjourney> SD3> Dalle> Adobe

-

2.Prompt：

A strong man riding a steel dragon flying in the sky, panorama, steel mecha, futuristic tech wind

Midjourney> Dalle> SD3> Adobe

-

3.Prompt：

An abstract three-dimensional sculpture in the shape of an orchid, composed of gemstones and frosted viscous materials, in the style of tesseract, light-filled, sparkling water reflections, sunrays shine upon it

Midjourney> Adobe> SD3> Dalle

-

4.Prompt：

woman smiling and having a cup of 7-eleven coffee outside a 7-eleven convenience store in the morning in the style of 90"s anime, 1990s anime texture and colors, thick line work

Midjourney> Dalle> SD3> Adobe

-

5.Prompt：

fantasy greatsword made from crimson metal, oil painting

Midjourney> SD3> Dalle> Adobe

-

6.Prompt：

a dark ocean with great Sturm, Captive Souls Pirate"s Redemption, ship emerging out of the fog, Giant octopus reaching out of the waters to pull down the ship

Midjourney> Dalle> SD3> Adobe

-

7.Prompt：

warhammer 40K, Islamic space marine, white armor, black and gold trim, matte paintin

Midjourney> SD3> Adobe> Dalle

-

8.Prompt：

oil painting of an angel with wings spread above the forest, light beam from its eyes illuminates path in bright green and blue colors

Midjourney> Adobe> SD3> Dalle

-

剩下case略。

在审美部分，Midjourney依然以绝对的优势压倒性胜利，而以设计起家的Adobe，反而拉了最大的跨。

三. 语义理解

主要测试AI绘图对于复杂语义的理解能力，能否将文本内容都能清晰的表达出来并保证生成图片的质量。

1.Prompt：

Portrait photograph of an anthropomorphic tortoise seated on a New York City subway train

Dalle >Midjourney> SD3> Adobe

-

2.Prompt：

A businessman on a throne. The AI agents gathered behind him like royal guards. Photo Real

Dalle>Midjourney> SD3> Adobe

-

3.Prompt：

A cup of coffee sitting on a table in front of a window, outside the window is a futuristic city; a futuristic monorail can be seen close by, many lush plants around, shot from ground floor, clouds above

Dalle> Adobe > SD3>Midjourney

-

4.Prompt：

A hyper-realistic image of an anthropomorphic corn cob working as a cashier at a convenience store, depicted with a cheerful expression while laughing. The corn cob, dressed in the store"s uniform, features a friendly face with eyes and a mouth on the husk, showing a big, joyful smile. The scene captures the corn cob scanning items at the cash register, wearing a typical convenience store uniform that includes a neat polo shirt and a name tag

Dalle>Midjourney> SD3> Adobe

-

5.Prompt：

Editorial photography of astronaut cooking Christmas colorful chocolate honey cookies on spaceship, Christmas honey cookies floating around astronaut, no gravity, in spaceship, levitated

Dalle>Midjourney> SD3> Adobe

-

6.Prompt：

a close up hyper realistic image of a medieval knight facing off against the grim reaper. Dramatic lighting

Dalle=Midjourney> Adobe > SD3

-

7.Prompt：

a very pretty young woman smilling flying over an aztec city with a dog, both the woman and the dog are flying, she is wearing an aztec outfit, the dog is wearing a colourful collar. they both seem to be having fun, ultra realistic

Dalle=Midjourney> Adobe > SD3

-

8.Prompt：

dungeons and dragons, high detailed, fantastic realism, female centaur with unicorn horn on head, hyper realistic

Midjourney > SD3 > Dalle> Adobe

-

剩下case略。

Dalle3和Midjourney基本上处于领先地位，Dalle还是领先一筹。Adobe继续垫底。

最后总结

在四个大模型三个维度评完了以后，我相信大家应该能对这几个大模型有大概的了解了。

但是为了更直观一些，我再来做个雷达图吧。

细节质量方面，MJ V6 > SD3 > Adobe Fiefly 3 > Dalle 3.

审美方面，MJ V6>SD3 >Dalle 3 >Adobe Fiefly 3.

语义理解方面，Dalle 3> MJ V6> SD3 >Adobe Fiefly 3.

MJ依然稳坐头把交椅，很多人跟我说，啥XX大模型在什么什么参数评测中已经超越了MJ啥啥的，我每次都点点头：哦。

而Adobe Fiefly 3的全面拉胯以至于我几度怀疑自己是不是选错了模型，直到我再三确认我选的确实就是Fiefly Image 3预览版。

就...拉胯的令人难以置信。

而SD3至少在我以API方式接入使用下，也没有很多自媒体或者其他人吹的那么神乎其神。

希望这个评测，能抛砖引玉吧，让大家对AI绘图综合有一些了解。

更建议的是，自己上手去试试。

又跑了十几个小时，虽然跟大家说的是只有42个Case，但是背后跑了不知道多少。希望能对大家有所帮助吧。